My Core Biopsy is Benign but I Need Surgery?
Question: My mammogram had some new calcifications and I underwent needle biopsy. My doctor said there was no cancer but that the calcifications weren’t in my biopsy. They say I need to have surgery but if everything is benign I don’t understand why? Can calcifications disappear?
Answer: I have seen this happen several times, unfortunately, so you’re not alone. The radiologist takes an “xray” of the biopsy after it is done to determine that he/she biopsied the calcifications so if their report says there were calcifications then there are several things you and your doctor can check: 1) did the pathologist “level” through the tissue block–this means did they do multiple slides through the block until it was all gone? Sometimes the calcifications are “deep” in the tissue block made in the Histology lab; 2) did the pathologist look for “calcium oxalate” which can be hard to see under the microscope unless the pathologist uses a special adaptor called a polarizer?; 3) you can ask to have your slides reviewed by another pathologist to confirm that there are no calcifications; 4) if none of these ideas help find the calcifications, you can ask if it’s possible to re-biopsy the area instead of going to surgery–sometimes this is possible, but sometimes it’s not preferable and surgery is recommended. I hope this helps.


Thanks for your information. I had my surgery yesterday without understanding . I ask myself the Biopsy is Benign and why i need surgery. I was confused and question myself many times and could not find answer. My surgeon said “calcifications may be calcium oxalate and give the report the same day and ask me to make appointment for surgery. I did ask her ” Do i have any option?”.
Without fully understand the pathology report. It is frustrating.
Thanks.
Carol
It seems you had some sort of biopsy (either a core or a fine needle aspiration biopsy) prior to your surgery. You didn’t mention what the diagnosis was. Calcium oxalate is just a type of “calcification” that can be seen on mammograms.
You can ask for a copy of your pathology report–that is your right as a patient. If you can let me know what that report said, I could possibly help out more. Right now I don’t know enough information to help you out.